1 or 2e. Can a caster "Forget a spell"?

Discuss any non D&D roleplaying topics here.

Moderator: Stik

Post Reply
User avatar
garhkal
Baronet
Baronet
Posts: 2141
Favorite D&D Edition: 2nd Edition
Contact:

1 or 2e. Can a caster "Forget a spell"?

Post by garhkal »

Lets say finenous the magister has 2 magic missiles, 1 sleep, 1 det magic, 2 blurs, 1 cont darkness, 1 fireball and 1 dispel magic in his memory... During the day he casts none, but realizes the group may instead of his blurs, need a few knocks the following day.
Can he simply forget his two blur spells? Or must he cast them to 'clean then out of his memory, so he can then memorize two knocks"?
If he does have to cast them, can he just start, then stop, causing it to fizzle much like if he got hit? if so, are any material components the spell calls for, consumed?

Additionally, i remember a rule somewhere (not sure if 1e or 2e) where when a caster is knocked out (or goes negatives), he loses all spells he had in his mind.. Anyone know where that's from?
User avatar
JadedDM
Guildmaster
Guildmaster
Posts: 711
Favorite D&D Edition: 2nd Edition
Location: Washington, USA

Re: 1 or 2e. Can a caster "Forget a spell"?

Post by JadedDM »

I allow spellcasters to forget spells. But forgetting is the same as casting, in the sense that you cannot refill that slot until you've rested.
garhkal wrote:Additionally, i remember a rule somewhere (not sure if 1e or 2e) where when a caster is knocked out (or goes negatives), he loses all spells he had in his mind.. Anyone know where that's from?
Hovering on Death's Door rule, in the 2E DMG.
User avatar
garhkal
Baronet
Baronet
Posts: 2141
Favorite D&D Edition: 2nd Edition
Contact:

Re: 1 or 2e. Can a caster "Forget a spell"?

Post by garhkal »

Thanks.. Knew it was somewhere.
User avatar
Halaster-Blackcloak
Knight
Knight
Posts: 1457
Favorite D&D Edition: 1st Edition

Re: 1 or 2e. Can a caster "Forget a spell"?

Post by Halaster-Blackcloak »

I'd say he has to cast them to "clear" them. He can't just "forget" them. Remember, spell energy is stored in his mind. That energy has to be released before he can re-energize, so to speak. If he dies and is resurrected or raised, all his memorized spells are wiped out. If using death's door rules, as JadedDM pointed out, the spells are likewise wiped out if he goes into the negative.
Post Reply